|
Monthly update April 2008
Welcome to BusinessHR's April update.
There are lots of changes in April - this being one of the two
key months for introducing changes to employment and health and
safety law, and it also coincides with the budget!
Topics:
- Employment law update
- Increase in statutory payments
- Changes to harassment law and to maternity benefits
- Scope of consultation legislation broadened
- Agency workers
- Changes to age legislation
- Finally a bit of new tax legislation
- Increase in the National Minimum Wage
- ID cards for all
- Some interesting cases....
- Health and safety update
- Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007
- Noise at work regulations extended to the music and
entertainment sector
- More guidance on DSE
- New on the website
- And finally....
- Recruitment - the need for a professional approach on both
sides
- Increase in redundancies
- Social networking websites
- And a new form of leave?
Employment law update
Increase in statutory payments
From 6th April 2008, statutory maternity, paternity and adoption
pay will increase from £112.75 per week to £117.18, and
statutory sick pay will increase from £72.55 per week to
£75.40.
The budget brought in a number of other changes:
- Changes to tax rates as follows:
- the 10% starting rate is removed
- the 22% basic rate is reduced to 20%
- The thresholds from which the rates apply are confirmed as:
- basic rate (20%) for £0 - £36,000
- higher rate (40%) - for earnings over £36,000
- The personal allowance for those under 65 increases to
£5,435. For those aged 65 -74 it is £9,030 and for those
aged 75 and over it is £9,180.
- There are no changes to the rates of NICs, but the upper
earnings limit increases by £75 per week above indexation.
- From 6 April 2008, the car fuel benefit charge multiplier is
increased from £14,400 to £16,900.
- There are no changes in the rates and thresholds for mileage
allowance payments for 2008/09.
- The Lifetime Allowance (the upper limit of the value of an
individual's 'pension pot') rose by £50,000 to £1.65
million. The annual allowance (the total amount that can be paid
into an individual's pension before a tax penalty is incurred)
rose by £10,000 to £235,000.
Changes to harassment law and to maternity benefits
We've covered the forthcoming changes to harassment law in past
newsletters, but this is just to confirm that, as from 6 April,
employers who know that a client or customer is sexually
harassing one of their female employees and who fail to take
such steps as would have been "reasonably practicable" to
protect the employee will be breaking the law. This means that
employers are required to protect female staff from unwanted
advances from customers and clients as well as colleagues. Those
most likely to benefit are women working in hotels, restaurants,
estate agencies, bars and shops and other jobs where there is
regular contact with members of the public. The employer has to
be aware of the harassment and this provision will only apply if
the employer knows that the woman has been subject to harassment
in the course of her employment on at least two other occasions
by a third party (though it is immaterial whether the third
party is the same or a different person on each occasion).
The definition of sex-related harassment under the Sex
Discrimination Act 1975 is also broadened: to "unwanted conduct
related to the complainant's sex or that of another person". So
individuals who are not subjected to the unwanted conduct
themselves will also receive protection - a male or female who
works in an environment where sexist banter is commonplace and
which, although not directed at that person or caused by their
presence, creates an offensive environment for them, is
protected.
Action to take:
- read our guide to harassment -
/docs/legal/harassment.html
- ensure that you have a robust policy for reporting/dealing
with allegations of harassment and that this covers harassment
by any party, not just by colleagues
- provide training for staff including equipping managers with
the skills to have potentially difficult conversations with
customers/clients
- where practicable, inform clients, customers and commercial
contacts of your policy (eg this could be done via a notice in
appropriate cases).
In addition, a woman is protected if she is not consulted about
a change to her job while on maternity leave or if promotion is
delayed because her maternity leave is excluded from length of
service. And as from 6 April, the Sex Discrimination Act will be
amended so that pregnant women do not need a comparator in cases
of alleged pregnancy or maternity discrimination - the woman
will instead only have to show that she has been treated less
favourably on the grounds of her pregnancy or the fact that she
has taken, or sought to take, statutory maternity leave.
And changes to terms and conditions during Additional Maternity
Leave, originally planned to take effect on 6 April 2008, will
now apply to women whose Expected Week of Childbirth (EWC) is on
or after 5 October 2008.
At the moment, a woman's employment continues throughout the
12-month maternity leave period, however women are only entitled
to benefit from their contractual terms and conditions (other
than pay) during the first 26 weeks - the "Ordinary Maternity
Leave" period. Some benefits continue during the period of paid
maternity leave (39 weeks) - these include pension contributions
(which must be based on the full pay the employee would receive
if working), life and private health insurance, medical cover,
and childcare vouchers. And only limited contractual terms and
conditions remain in place during the final 13 weeks (notice
provisions, the implied term of trust and confidence,
disciplinary and grievance procedures, any enhanced redundancy
terms, accrual of statutory holiday).
As from 5 October 2008 women will be entitled to benefit from
all non-pay benefits during the entire maternity leave
period - so all terms and conditions which would have applied
had they been at work, except for the terms providing for
remuneration (wages or salary). This covers all contractual
benefits such as contractual holiday entitlement, health club
membership, private use of a company car etc. Employers will
also have to include any period of additional maternity leave
taken by employees when calculating their length of service for
the purpose of contractual benefits. Currently, when
calculating contractual bonuses, any period spent on compulsory
maternity leave (ie the two week period immediately following
childbirth) must be included as though the employee had been at
work and working normally - the 2008 Regulations amend the Sex
Discrimination Act so that the same principle is applied to
non-contractual bonuses.
Action to take:
- review all non-pay benefits, if necessary, revise your
policies and your budgets to allow for the increase from October
- change your leave records so that full contractual leave
accrues during the entire maternity leave period
- review any bonus schemes to ensure that the period of
compulsory maternity leave attracts such bonuses
- update your maternity policy, or employee handbook,
accordingly.
Scope of consultation legislation broadened
As from 6 April 2008, the scope of the Information and
Consultation of Employees Regulations 2004, and also of the
Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Consultation by
Employers and Miscellaneous Amendment) Regulations 2006 is
extended to undertakings with 50 or more employees.
For more details re the former, see
/docs/legal/consult.html
Agency workers
And on the same date, the Conduct of Employment Agencies and
Employment Businesses (Amendment) Regulations 2007 take effect -
these will give all agency workers the right to withdraw from
services provided by an agency, such as accommodation and
transport, without suffering any disadvantage. Agencies will no
longer be required to provide written information to workers
regarding assignments of less than five days.
See: /docs/legal/agency.html
Changes to age legislation
Also with effect from 6 April 2008 there are some minor changes
to the age discrimination regulations, dealing with continuity
of service for the service-related benefit exception; and
closing a loophole in connection with time limits (the original
Regulations did not properly provide for the three month
extension of time under the dispute resolution regulations).
Finally a bit of tax legislation
A previous loophole, which allowed HMRC to charge an employer
full tax and NI under the PAYE regulations, where the parties
have wrongly viewed the employee as self-employed, and without
giving credit for the tax and national insurance already paid
directly by the 'employee', is now closed. So HMRC can no
longer charge tax twice!
Increase in the National Minimum Wage
Not until October, but advance warning that that the new rates of
the National Minimum Wage, applicable from 1 October 2008, will
be as follows:
- for workers aged 22 and over - an increase from £5.52
per hour to £5.73
- for workers aged 18-21 - an increase from £4.60 to
£4.77 and
- for workers aged 16 and 17 (provided they are above
compulsory school age) - an increase from £3.40 to
£3.53.
The increase in the adult rate is 3.8 per cent so just above
inflation and is expected to benefit more than a million low
paid workers, the majority (two thirds) of which are women.
The figure for accommodation to be offset will rise from
£4.30 per day to £4.46 per day (equivalent to £31.22
for a 7-day period).
The Low Pay Commission's remit for 2008/09 is to:
- monitor, evaluate and review the NMW and its impact
- review the levels of each of the different minimum wage
rates and make recommendations for October 2009 and provisional
rate recommendations for October 2010
- review the current apprentice exemptions, bearing in mind
the Government's target to increase apprenticeships
- report to the Prime Minister and Secretary of State for
Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform by the end of
February 2009.
And in the meantime, the government proposes to strengthen the
enforcement of the National Minimum Wage and introduce tougher
penalties, including unlimited fines, for employers who fail to
pay at the correct rates. The Bill is currently progressing
through Parliament and is expected to come into force on 1
October 2008 to coincide with the rate increase.
See: /docs/legal/minimumwage.html
ID cards for all
The Home Office has announced that ID cards will be introduced
this year for foreign nationals and then for British citizens in
2009. British citizens enrolled on the National Identity Register
will also eventually have the choice of having a passport or an
ID card or both. Consultation on various aspects of the
proposals will run until 30 June.
See:
www.bia.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/newsarticles/identityschemeplan
Some interesting cases....
Another age discrimination claim from a young employee
We reported the case of Megan Thomas, aged 20, who was dismissed
from her post at the Eight Member Club in London, after six
months employment, as her employer felt that she was too young.
Compensation in her case was limited, as she obtained another
(better paid) job immediately - so the damages were restricted
to a small amount of compensation for injury to feelings and
unpaid notice.
In a second, similar case, an 18 year old administrator has won
more than £16,000 for age discrimination - a much higher
award! In Wilkinson v Springwell Engineering Limited,
Miss Wilkinson was employed as an office administrator. During
her probationary period, the employer decided that she was not
performing sufficiently well and she was therefore told that her
performance must improve over the following few months. Another,
older, office administrator was asked to assist with her work
load. After two months' employment, Miss Wilkinson was dismissed
and she alleged that her line manager said that this was because
she was too young for the job.
Her claim was successful as the employer failed to provide
evidence that she lacked capability to do the job
satisfactorily. The tribunal stated that Springwell had relied
on a "stereotypical" assumption that capability equals
experience and experience equals older age. Miss Wilkinson's
award included compensation for future loss of earnings for six
months and £5,000 for injury to feelings, plus a 50%
increase in the award due to her employer's failure to follow
the statutory dismissal and disciplinary procedures.
Note: prior to dismissing a probationary employee, check that
you properly document his/her shortcomings, so that you can
provide evidence if necessary, of lack of capability. Where
appropriate, keep work samples on file for a while (eg where
there are excessive errors, poor grammar or punctuation,
excessive time taken to do certain jobs etc.)
Changing contracts
In Robinson v Tescom Corporation, the employee may have
been confused about the action he should take when faced with an
employer who wanted to change his contract. The employee, Mr
Robinson, was a sales manager who objected to an extension to
his sales area. He agreed to the changes 'under protest' but
then refused to work under the new terms and insisted on working
under his original terms. Following a disciplinary hearing he was
dismissed for gross misconduct.
The EAT said that his choices were either to
- accept the variation
- resign and claim constructive dismissal
- refuse to work under the new terms and force the employer to
take what steps it thinks appropriate or,
- work under protest and seek damages (for breach of
contract).
Since he had agreed to the new terms, under protest, Mr
Robinson's contract of employment continued and he could not
therefore then renege on this agreement, so the decision to
dismiss him was deemed fair as Mr Robinson was refusing to
follow a reasonable management instruction.
Health and safety update
Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007
A final reminder that this new piece of legislation, which
creates a criminal offence of "corporate manslaughter" and
allows companies to be prosecuted for any death in the
workplace, takes effect on 6 April 2008. For further details
see our February hot topic or see
/docs/hasaw/manslaughter.html
From 6 April. all workplace deaths will be investigated by the
police with input from the Health and Safety Executive, which
will play a supporting role. This will bring major changes as
the workplace will be a crime scene, and may be sealed off. So
given that the police would also want to be able to contact
witnesses, do ensure that you keep contact details of all staff
somewhere secure but accessible off site, together with any data
required to keep the business functioning (this is good practice
anyway in terms of dealing with emergencies such as fire, flood,
electricity failure, etc).
As you are aware the fines for corporate manslaughter are
unlimited, they are criminal fines, and a recent government
consultation recommended that they should be based on turnover -
between 2.5% -10% of gross annual turnover, averaged over the
preceding three year period. If adopted, this would lead to much
larger fines than we've been used to - the highest fine to date
for a safety breach was £15M imposed on Transco - if based
on turnover, it could have been £45M.
Noise at work regulations extended to the music and entertainment sector
When the Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005 came into
force, an initial exemption applied to work in the music and
entertainment sector. This exemption ceases on 6 April 2008.
Under the 2005 Regulations, the level at which employers must
provide hearing protection and hearing protection zones is 85
decibels (daily or weekly average exposure) and the level at
which employers must assess the risk to workers' health and
provide them with information and training is 80 decibels. There
is also an exposure limit value of 87 decibels, taking account of
any reduction in exposure provided by hearing protection, above
which workers must not be exposed.
The HSE has promised practical guidelines specific to the music
and entertainment industry - these should be available by 6
April 2008.
More guidance on DSE
The Health and Safety Executive has a new section on its website
dedicated to offering advice on display screen equipment (DSE),
which includes computer monitors. It includes guidance on safe
working with monitors, case studies, how to carry out a DSE
assessment, and advice for call centre working practices.
See: www.hse.gov.uk/msd/dse/index.htm
New on the website
We've added three new letters - two regarding the right of appeal
against a flexible working request which has been denied (the
first invites the employee to an appeal meeting; the second
confirms the outcome) and a letter warning an employee who is
about to run out of either company or statutory sick pay.
See:
/docs/lf/flex/index.html and
/docs/lf/sickpay/index.html
And finally....
Recruitment - the need for a professional approach on both sides
How effective are your recruitment procedures?
Recent research found that almost 9 in 10 respondents admitted
to giving jobs to the most attractive candidate and 92% said
that a candidate's appearance during the interview can influence
their decision. Not only does this not necessarily get you the
best person for the job, but it could be discrimination - if for
example, an applicant's weight problem is due to illness. DO
ensure that your interviewers are trained to conduct interviews
effectively (using the job description as their starting point)
and that they know how to avoid discriminatory questions. A
poll by T-Mobile found that more than 50% of potential recruits
who left an interview with a bad impression of the company cited
the interviewer as the reason. Being asked questions completely
unrelated to the job, or facing an unprepared interviewer were
common, but there were also findings suggesting 16% of
interviewees experienced sexism, and 7% experienced racism when
being interviewed for a role.
And whilst employers might be putting off potential employees as
a result of bad interview techniques, this seems to work both
ways! A poll of interviewers reveals that 78% felt that
swearing during an interview is not likely to get you a job,
answering a mobile phone is not a good idea (76% cited this),
wearing inappropriate clothing such as jeans or scruffy clothes
put off 50% and 49% would not give a job to a candidate who
arrived more than 10 minutes late.
So some lessons for both sides here!
Increase in redundancies
The winter CIPD/KPMG Labour Market Outlook (LMO) survey shows a
sharp increase in the proportion of employers expecting to make
at least some staff redundant in the coming months - almost 38%
intended to make some redundancies this quarter. This is borne
out by our helpline and by our PAYG sales - where redundancy
sadly, is a favourite topic.
Over 70 per cent of senior management in another survey of 200
businesses (Pentacle, The Virtual Business School) admit UK
bosses have little or no experience of how to deal with a
downturn and over two-thirds (69 per cent) of executives believe
the UK is now heading into a recession or serious downturn. 74
per cent of junior staff confess that insecurity, distraction
and "fear of the chop" may damage struggling businesses further,
as workers vie to impress those at the top.
If your business is facing redundancies, do be aware of the
procedures which should be followed: these are usually quite
straightforward, but failure to comply with the detail may make
a dismissal unfair. So read our guides on redundancy and use
the template forms: /docs/TPend.html
Social networking websites
There has been a marked increase in the use of networking
websites, both professional and social. The social ones, the
best known being MySpace and Facebook, were set up as extensions
to the use of blogs and chat rooms so people can interact and
exchange thoughts and ideas over the internet. These in
particular are aimed mostly at a young clientele, who happen to
have a casual or familiar attitude to the internet. Even the
TUC is warning employers via its website that the UK's Facebook
users are "3.5 million accidents waiting to happen."
Many organisations (rightly) updated their IT policies in light
of the popularity and sometimes inappropriate or excessive
personal use of the internet at work - (mis)use of company
property and time etc. Now additional problems are occurring
relating to the content of these exchanges. What might have
previously have been a moan amongst workmates face to face, can
now be noted on line on a networking website, opening up all the
negative vibes for anyone who logs on to see! This is
potentially very damaging to reputation and may even
reveal/disclose confidential information (possibly even a breach
of contract).
If you want to protect your business you should consider what
you would do if there was negative chat on a social network site
- then be proactive and address this to hopefully prevent it
occurring.
Action to take:
- Check that either your contracts or your disciplinary
procedure cites 'bringing the company into disrepute' amongst
the disciplinary offences. This may allow you to nip any
offences in the bud, thereby showing a serious stance.
- Check your IT policy and ensure that it specifies what
private use of the internet is permitted, including the use of
social networking sites (if you permit this - some employers ban
these altogether).
- Check any confidentiality agreements to ensure that you can
take action on comments which criticise your organisation.
Include in your handbook that employees must obtain consent
before making public comments about you or your organisation and
encourage
greater use of your internal grievance procedures to allow
employees to vent any negative opinions.
- Recent case law has tended to protect personal privacy re
use of email etc at work. However, in this situation the
internet use may well be in personal rather than work time but
cannot anyway be regarded as private if posted on a public ie
accessible site. So set out your stance on this issue - many
breaches are probably due to naivety or lack of thought - such
breaches would be prevented by telling your employees in advance
what you will and will not condone and putting in place some
sensible guidelines.There is a mutual duty of care between
employer and employee and it might be an idea to remind
employees of this (they tend to remember only one side).
- Dealing with ex-employees may be more difficult and rely on
post-employment confidential clauses which are of course more
difficult to enforce.
- Be wary yourself of using such sites to check out details of
candidates whom you may be interested in recruiting.
As only a minority of potential recruits will have public
profiles on social networks, using information from these
sources can give an unfair advantage or disadvantage to certain
candidates - and therefore probably does not sit well with your
equal opportunities policy!
For further guidance refer to the disciplinary section of our
website:
/docs/TPduringdiscipline.html
and also the template IT policy and disciplinary procedure -
/docs/TPcontract.html
And a new form of leave?
We were interested to read about a Japanese marketing firm which
offers "heartbreak leave". Designed for those who need to take
paid time off following a break up with a partner, the amount of
leave also caught our eye as it would potentially contravene our
age discrimination legislation! Staff in their twenties are
given up to 2 days off per year, older staff have three.
Somehow we don't see this catching on in the UK but you never
know!
|